info@holocaustcentre.org.nz Open daily from 10 - 1pm (closed Saturdays, public holidays and some Jewish holidays)
Holocaust Centre of New Zealand

​​Shop

​​Donate
Contact us​

​
  • Home
  • ABOUT
    • Annual Report & AGM
    • HCNZ History
    • Board / Management
    • Visit Our Centre >
      • General Information
      • Planning Your Visit
      • Group Booking Form
      • School Booking Form
    • Patron / Advisors
    • Mission & Strategy
  • Educate
    • What was the Holocaust?
    • Anne Frank - Aotearoa NZ
    • Children's Holocaust Memorial >
      • CHM Background
      • CHM Education Resources & Venues
    • Educators >
      • Finding Hope - Exhibition
      • Holocaust Timeline
      • Human Rights Lessons
      • Modern Anti-Semitism
      • NZ Curriculum: Senior History
      • NZ Curriculum: Social Studies
      • School Booking Form
      • Teaching Guide
      • Teaching Trunks Project
      • Yad Vashem Seminar
    • Holocaust Resources >
      • Websites
      • Literature/Speeches
      • Films
      • Righteous Among the Nations
    • Human Rights >
      • Holocaust Lessons
      • Our HR Work
    • Just One Week
    • Public >
      • Our Exhibition
      • Adult Education
    • Students >
      • Annual Composition Prize
      • FAQs
      • Planning Research Visits
  • School Programmes
    • Judaism & Pre-War Jewish Life
    • Understanding the Holocaust
    • Resistance, Rebellion, & Righteousness
    • Holocaust Media Studies
    • Liberation to New Life: Migration to New Zealand
    • Holocaust Research
  • Support The Centre
    • Bequests
    • Corporate
    • Donate
    • Membership
    • Volunteer
  • TESTIMONY
    • Generations After
    • NZ & The Holocaust >
      • Holocaust NZ Timeline
      • Jewish Contribution to NZ
    • NZ Survivors
    • International Survivors
    • Righteous Among the Nations
  • WHAT'S ON
    • Archive
    • Events >
      • Commemorations
      • Films
      • Music
      • Presentations / Exhibitions
      • Seminars
    • Media/News/Speeches >
      • Media Releases
      • News
      • Speeches >
        • Blog

US Policy of Immigrant Family Separation – Nuanced Parallels with the Holocaust

29/10/2018

0 Comments

 
Marc Daalder
​

Since the United States government began enforcing a policy that resulted in the separation of families of undocumented immigrants at the US-Mexico border, commentators around the world have referenced the Holocaust in denouncing these acts. Of course, this isn’t the first human rights issue which has been compared to the Holocaust and it won’t be the last either.
 
In my previous blog posts, I have both insisted on the necessity of using Holocaust scholarship to combat human rights abuses and discussed the dangers of idly referencing the Holocaust. Given this, how should we evaluate these claims? Should we support them because the “Never Again” is a call to action, or oppose them because they minimize the Holocaust?
 
There is no easy or blanket answer to these questions. There often are valid comparisons to be made between, for example, xenophobia and hate in the modern day and that which lead up to the Holocaust. Moreover, while most violations of human rights do not escalate to genocide, it would be untrue to say this never happened. We can learn from the fact that few anticipated the true horror of the Holocaust even as it had already begun.
 
At the same time, if every individual assault or hate crime is comparable to the Holocaust, then doesn’t that minimize the Holocaust? Whether or not the Holocaust was unique in the annals of history is a different academic debate, but it was certainly among the worst genocides ever undertaken – it is not equitable to most violations of human rights.
 
In the end, it is perhaps intent that matters. Comparing the Holocaust to modern-day violations in a nuanced manner allows for those violations to be elevated in the public consciousness. This is a good thing. To say, for example, that a violation “resembles the Holocaust in methodology if not in magnitude,” would be an appropriate use of the comparison.
 
Furthermore, linking today’s violations to specific aspects of the Holocaust should also be encouraged. When it is reported that parents on the US-Mexico border are told their children are being taken for a bath when they are in fact being incarcerated, to not mention the obvious Holocaust parallel is to do a disservice to the victims of both atrocities.
 
I think every comparison must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, and good intent, nuance, and narrow scope are always preferred. In general, however, I lean towards permitting such comparisons because I believe that those who have studied the Holocaust have the obligation to share the lessons they have learned with the world.

These views are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Holocaust Centre of New Zealand.
​
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

DIRECTIONS

Picture





​80 Webb Street, Te Aro
Wellington, 6011
New Zealand
04 801 9480

OPEN HOURS

 Monday: 10am - 1pm
Tuesday: 10am - 1pm
Wednesday: 10am - 1pm
Thursday: 10am - 1pm
Friday: 10am - 1pm
Saturday: closed  (&
 some Public & Jewish Holidays )
Sunday: 10am - 1pm
​(10am -  4pm last Sunday of each month)
Donate
© 2018 All rights reserved Holocaust Centre of New Zealand | Website by WebXperts Ltd

DETAILS:

Picture
80 Webb Street
Te Aro
Wellington, 6011
New Zealand
04 801 9480
info@holocaustcentre.org.nz

DIRECTIONS:

HOURS:

Monday: 10am - 1pm
Tuesday: 10am - 1pm
Wednesday: 10am - 1pm
Thursday: 10am - 1pm
Friday: 10am - 1pm
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: 10am - 1pm

Join Our Mailing List

* indicates required